已开启
docs: add DFR reliability review report for service-side code #4978
docs: add DFR reliability review report for service-side code #4978
已开启
wangsen1994创建于 8月12日
wangsen1994
wangsen1994
8月12日

关联 Issue

Closes #4325

变更说明

新增通知服务侧代码可靠性评审(DFR)报告文件 docs/dfr-reliability-review-report.md。

评审范围

  • services/ans/、services/distributed/、services/domain/、services/infrastructure/
  • 排除 services/reminder/(非本项目维护)

可靠性目标

  • 服务不卡死/不挂死
  • 进程不崩溃/OOM
  • 通知业务不中断

评审结果概要

共识别 25个去重风险点(D级架构设计10个 + C级编码15个),其中严酷度I级10个、II级13个、III级8个。

P0 最高优先级(I级)

  1. 持锁期间同步IPC(D级,13+处)— 系统性设计缺陷,双路径交叉验证命中
  2. notificationList_ 无锁并发访问(D级)— 核心数据结构无锁,三路径交叉验证
  3. 分布式死亡回调空实现(D级)— OnRemoteDied 仅打日志无恢复

P1 次高优先级(I级)

  1. 流控实现bug(C级)— distributed_flow_control.cpp:36 变量名错误,可直接修复
  2. onCorruption无备份删除数据库(D级)— H-05高危操作
  3. 软总线SendMessage无超时(D级)— 永久挂起风险
  4. packageCached_无界队列(D级)— OOM风险
  5. GetDeviceList返回引用(D级)— 数据竞争

置信度

  • 整体置信度:中-高
  • 双路径交叉验证命中:持锁IPC、notificationList_无锁、OnRemoteDied空实现、RecoverDatabase竞态等
  • 所有风险点均为推理风险,建议通过故障注入测试进一步确认

检查方法

  • 双路径(自上而下 + 自下而上)
  • 3个 subagent 并行分析3个独立区域
  • 故障模式库:内置扩展版(11大类60+故障模式)
likedislike
合并受阻
wangsen1994wangsen1994
8月12日 关联了issue:[DFR] 通知服务侧代码可靠性评审 — 25个风险点(10个I级)
afwk_helper成员
8月12日 评论:

开始进行AI检视!

AI review has been started, please wait...

likedislike
afwk_helper成员
8月12日 评论:
check type result report
start ai_review pass -
likedislike
afwk_helper成员
8月12日 评论:

⏱️ AI检视超时通知 / AI Review Timeout Notification

AI代码检视任务执行时间过长(已耗时: 0:00:10),任务已超时终止。

The AI code review task has been running for too long (elapsed: 0:00:10) and has timed out.

建议 / Suggestions:

  1. 稍后重试 / Try again later
  2. 如果问题持续,请联系管理员 / If the issue persists, please contact the administrator
  3. 检查AI服务状态 / Check AI service status

错误详情 / Error Details: HTTPSConnectionPool(host='openharmonyinsight.cn', port=443): Max retries exceeded with url: /api/v1/review (Caused by ConnectTimeoutError(<HTTPSConnection(host='openharmonyinsight.cn', port=443) at 0x7f42e869a980>, 'Connection to openharmonyinsight.cn timed out. (connect timeout=10)'))

likedislike
openharmony_ci
openharmony_ci成员
8月12日 评论:

感谢提交 Pull Requests !此PR未通过DCO校验。
校验失败可能原因:

1. 未签署“DCO协议”(开发者原创声明协议),在线签署、查看签署状态。

2. Commits 中未包含 Signed-off-by信息,参考FAQ处理。

修复上述问题后,在PR的评论框输入“check dco” ,单击”评论”,系统将再次进行DCO校验。

当前检测到如下Commits 未包含Signed-off-by信息:


Thanks for submitting a pull request. This pull request has not passed the DCO check.
Possible causes:

1. You have not signed the Developer Certificate of Origin (DCO). Sign the DCO and check DCO status.

2. The commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information. To resolve this issue, see FAQs.

After resolving the preceding issues, enter check dco in the comment box of this pull request and click Comment. The system will check DCO status again.

The following commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information:

likedislike
openharmony_ciopenharmony_ci成员
8月12日 添加了label:waiting_on_author
openharmony_ciopenharmony_ci成员
8月12日 添加了label:dco检查失败
wangsen1994wangsen1994
8月12日 推送  1 个提交:c9cc736c-docs: add dependency module fault propagation analysis
openharmony_ci
openharmony_ci成员
8月12日 评论:

感谢提交 Pull Requests !此PR未通过DCO校验。
校验失败可能原因:

1. 未签署“DCO协议”(开发者原创声明协议),在线签署、查看签署状态。

2. Commits 中未包含 Signed-off-by信息,参考FAQ处理。

修复上述问题后,在PR的评论框输入“check dco” ,单击”评论”,系统将再次进行DCO校验。

当前检测到如下Commits 未包含Signed-off-by信息:


Thanks for submitting a pull request. This pull request has not passed the DCO check.
Possible causes:

1. You have not signed the Developer Certificate of Origin (DCO). Sign the DCO and check DCO status.

2. The commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information. To resolve this issue, see FAQs.

After resolving the preceding issues, enter check dco in the comment box of this pull request and click Comment. The system will check DCO status again.

The following commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information:

likedislike
wangsen1994wangsen1994
8月12日 推送  1 个提交:d77995cb-docs: add key fault mode, ANS protection mechanism, importance columns
openharmony_ci
openharmony_ci成员
8月12日 评论:

感谢提交 Pull Requests !此PR未通过DCO校验。
校验失败可能原因:

1. 未签署“DCO协议”(开发者原创声明协议),在线签署、查看签署状态。

2. Commits 中未包含 Signed-off-by信息,参考FAQ处理。

修复上述问题后,在PR的评论框输入“check dco” ,单击”评论”,系统将再次进行DCO校验。

当前检测到如下Commits 未包含Signed-off-by信息:


Thanks for submitting a pull request. This pull request has not passed the DCO check.
Possible causes:

1. You have not signed the Developer Certificate of Origin (DCO). Sign the DCO and check DCO status.

2. The commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information. To resolve this issue, see FAQs.

After resolving the preceding issues, enter check dco in the comment box of this pull request and click Comment. The system will check DCO status again.

The following commits do not contain the Signed-off-by information:

likedislike
openharmony_dcp
openharmony_dcp成员
24 天前 评论:

您好, @wangsen1994 该PR需要您响应,已过去25天未响应,请根据检视意见进行修改,如5天内未响应检视意见,此PR会被自动关闭。关闭后的PR,如有需要,您可以自行打开该PR。

likedislike