1dba122c创建于 1 天前历史提交

Tool approval mode

Tool approval has two independent inputs:

  1. Tool declaration — every tool may declare an approval tier:
    • read: reads data or updates UI-only session metadata.
    • write: mutates workspace/session state but does not execute arbitrary code.
    • exec: executes code, shells out, drives a browser, spawns agents, or performs similarly broad actions.
  2. User policytools.approval.<toolName>: allow | deny | prompt overrides the mode for that tool unless a non-yolo safety override forces a prompt.

Tools without an approval declaration are treated as exec. This is the safe default for MCP and unknown custom tools.

Modes

Configure with tools.approvalMode:

Mode Auto-approves Prompts for
always-ask read write, exec
write read, write exec
yolo (default) read, write, exec none

--auto-approve and --yolo force tools.approvalMode: yolo for the session.

User overrides

tools.approval is honored in every mode:

tools:
  approvalMode: write
  approval:
    bash: prompt
    read: allow
    mcp__filesystem__delete: deny

Resolution per tool call:

  1. Compute the tool's approval decision from tool.approval(args); omitted means exec.
  2. Normalize tools.approval.<tool> if present; invalid values are ignored.
  3. In yolo mode, the user policy is used when present; otherwise the call is allowed. Safety override reasons do not force a prompt in yolo.
  4. In non-yolo modes, if the tool sets override: true, deny is blocked and all other cases prompt, even if user policy says allow.
  5. Otherwise, a valid user policy wins.
  6. Otherwise, the active mode auto-approves or prompts by tier.

Safety overrides

A tool can force a prompt with object-form approval:

approval: { tier: "exec", override: true, reason: "Critical pattern detected" }

bash uses this for critical destructive patterns such as rm -rf /, fork bombs, remote-fetch-then-execute, writes to /etc/passwd, and host shutdown commands. These surface as reason in the approval prompt, but in yolo mode they are auto-approved unless a user policy for the tool is set to prompt or deny.

Per-tool prompt details

Tools can add approval-prompt body lines with formatApprovalDetails(args). The standard prompt includes:

  • Allow tool: <name>
  • Origin: MCP server tool for unannotated mcp__... tools
  • Reason: <reason> when the tool decision supplies one
  • tool-specific details such as command, path, code, browser action, or subagent assignment

Defining approval on tools

Built-in and custom tools share the same shape:

export type ToolTier = "read" | "write" | "exec";
export type ToolApprovalDecision = ToolTier | { tier: ToolTier; reason?: string; override?: boolean };
export type ToolApproval = ToolApprovalDecision | ((args: unknown) => ToolApprovalDecision);

approval?: ToolApproval;
formatApprovalDetails?: (args: unknown) => string | string[] | undefined;

Examples:

approval: "read";

approval: (args) => (LSP_READONLY_ACTIONS.has(args.action) ? "read" : "write");

approval: (args) =>
  isCritical(args.command)
    ? { tier: "exec", override: true, reason: "Critical pattern detected" }
    : "exec";

Subagents

Subagents run headless with tools.approvalMode: yolo so they do not stall waiting for UI. The parent task approval is the authorization boundary. User tools.approval.<tool> settings continue to control whether a tool is allowed, prompted, or blocked.